Master Loddie’s knife throwing challenges in Hollow Knight Silksong with our complete guide. Get tips, rewards breakdown, and strategies to save Rosary Beads.
TL;DR
Loddie’s knife throwing challenges in The Marrow offer exclusive rewards but have strict rules: don’t cross the red marker and don’t miss 3 times. The 15-hit challenge rewards a Tool Pouch expansion, while the 25-hit challenge gives you a Heavy Rosary Necklace with 220 Rosaries. Success requires patience, pattern recognition, and strategic timing.
Hidden in the depths of The Marrow, you’ll stumble upon one of Hollow Knight Silksong’s most rewarding mini-games. Loddie’s knife throwing challenges might seem like simple carnival games at first glance, but they’re deceptively complex tests of timing, patience, and precision that can make or break your Rosary Bead collection.
What makes Loddie’s challenges particularly notorious isn’t just their difficulty – it’s how the game deliberately withholds crucial information until you’ve already failed. Let’s break down everything you need to know to conquer these challenges without emptying your wallet.
Finding Loddie: Your Gateway to Precision Gaming
Loddie sets up shop in a secluded corner of The Marrow, making him easy to miss if you’re rushing through the area. Unlike other merchants who announce themselves with obvious signage, Loddie’s setup is more subtle – look for the distinctive throwing range setup with targets and a red marker on the ground.
The Marrow itself can be a challenging area to navigate, so having your map properly filled out before attempting these challenges is essential. You don’t want to stumble into this high-stakes mini-game unprepared.
The Unforgiving Rules: What Loddie Doesn’t Tell You
Here’s where things get deliberately tricky. Loddie explains his rules only after you break them – a classic Team Cherry move that catches unsuspecting players off guard. The challenge operates under two non-negotiable rules:
Rule #1: Respect the Red Marker
That red line on the ground isn’t just decoration – crossing it instantly disqualifies you. This boundary forces you to work within a specific range, making precision shots more challenging than if you could simply walk closer to your target.
Rule #2: Three Strikes and You’re Out
Miss three times, and you’re done. A counter behind Hornet’s position tracks your failures, creating mounting pressure with each missed throw. There’s no mercy system, no “almost hits” – either you nail the target or you add to your miss count.
The consequences are immediate and expensive: fail either rule, and you’ll pay the 25 Rosary Bead entry fee again. This isn’t pocket change, especially early in the game when every bead counts toward crucial upgrades.
Challenge #1: The 15-Hit Precision Test
Reward: Tool Pouch Expansion
The first challenge establishes the foundation for everything that follows. You need 15 successful hits while the target bug gradually increases its complexity through four distinct phases:
Phase Breakdown:
- Hits 1-5: Completely stationary target – your warm-up phase
- Hits 6-8: Slow vertical movement with increasing speed
- Hits 9-12: Fixed wave pattern movement
- Hits 13-15: Teleportation between three static locations
The key insight: Every movement is predetermined and cyclical. This isn’t random AI behavior – it’s a pattern you can learn and exploit.
Winning Strategy for the 15-Hit Challenge
Wait for the low points. Hornet’s jump animation has inherent lag between button press and peak height. Targeting the bug when it’s near the ground accounts for this delay and significantly improves your accuracy.
Study before shooting. Since there’s no time limit, take advantage of the pressure-free environment. Watch the target complete 2-3 movement cycles before committing to each throw. This patience pays dividends, especially during the teleportation phase where memorizing the sequence is crucial.
The Tool Pouch expansion you’ll earn is invaluable for carrying additional crafting materials and quest items, making this challenge worth the investment even beyond the satisfaction of completion.
Challenge #2: The 25-Hit Endurance Trial
Reward: Heavy Rosary Necklace (220 Rosaries)
If the first challenge was about learning the basics, the second challenge is about mastering them under pressure. The target moves faster, more erratically, and the extended length means more opportunities for costly mistakes.
Extended Phase Breakdown:
- Hits 1-3: Stationary (shorter grace period)
- Hits 4-9: Accelerating vertical movement
- Hits 10-12: Fixed wave patterns (faster than Challenge #1)
- Hits 13-17: Erratic wave and diagonal patterns
- Hits 18-25: High-speed teleportation between 3-4 locations
Advanced Strategies for the 25-Hit Challenge
The erratic phase (hits 13-17) is a trap. While the movement looks random, the target still operates within fixed boundaries. Don’t let the apparent chaos fool you – there’s still predictability here if you look for it.
Teleportation becomes easier, not harder. During the final phase, memorize the teleport spots and predict where the target will appear next. This is actually more reliable than trying to track erratic movement patterns.
Distance matters for timing. The straight pin has travel time, so prioritize closer teleport spots over distant ones. By the time your pin reaches a far target, it might have already blinked away.
The Economics of Excellence: Risk vs. Reward
Is the 25 Rosary Bead entry fee worth it? Let’s break down the math:
Challenge #1 Economics:
- Cost: 25 Rosary Beads
- Reward: Tool Pouch expansion (utility value)
- Risk assessment: Moderate (learnable patterns)
Challenge #2 Economics:
- Cost: 25 Rosary Beads
- Reward: 220 Rosary Beads (net gain of 195)
- Risk assessment: High (extended difficulty)
The second challenge offers an impressive 780% return on investment if you succeed on your first attempt. Even if you fail once and succeed on the second try, you’re still looking at a 340% return. This makes it one of the most lucrative activities in the game.
Mental Game: Handling the Pressure
The psychological aspect is often overlooked but crucial for success. As your hit counter climbs and you approach the final phases, the pressure can lead to rushed throws and unnecessary misses.
Develop a pre-throw routine: Take a deep breath, study the pattern for 2-3 cycles, and only then commit to your throw. This consistency helps maintain accuracy even as the difficulty ramps up.
Don’t chase perfect runs. It’s better to take an extra few seconds per throw than to rush and accumulate misses. Remember, there’s no time limit – use this to your advantage.
Beyond The Marrow: Future Challenges?
Loddie hints at “much trickier challenges” in his dialogue, suggesting he might appear in other locations throughout Pharloom. While we’ve only encountered him in The Marrow so far, keep an eye out during your exploration of other regions.
This potential for additional challenges makes mastering his current tests even more valuable – you’ll want the practice and rewards before facing whatever greater difficulties await.
Advanced Tips for Consistent Success
Practice your throwing arc. Spend time in other areas of the game using throwing pins in combat. The muscle memory transfers directly to Loddie’s challenges.
Manage your Shell Shards and inventory before attempting these challenges. You don’t want to be distracted by inventory management when you need full focus.
Consider your progression timing. While these challenges are available relatively early, you might want to attempt them after gaining more experience with the game’s throwing mechanics through natural gameplay.
Available across Steam, Nintendo Switch, PlayStation, and Xbox, Silksong’s attention to mini-game detail shows Team Cherry’s commitment to varied, engaging content.
The Final Throw: Making Every Shot Count
Loddie’s challenges represent everything that makes Silksong special – deceptive simplicity hiding genuine depth. What appears to be a simple carnival game reveals layers of strategy, pattern recognition, and mental fortitude.
The rewards justify the risk, but more importantly, mastering these challenges builds skills that transfer to every aspect of Hornet’s journey. Precision, patience, and pattern recognition serve you well whether you’re facing boss encounters or navigating complex platforming sequences.
Take your time, study the patterns, and remember – in Loddie’s world, patience isn’t just a virtue, it’s the difference between profit and bankruptcy. Every successful throw brings you closer to mastery of one of Silksong’s most satisfying and rewarding challenges.
