The highly anticipated co-op MMORPG Ashes of Creation finally launched its early access phase on Steam, and the results are… complicated. While the game attracted an impressive 30,000 concurrent players on day one, it’s currently sitting at a “Mixed” review score that has fans worried about its future.
After nearly a decade in development, Ashes of Creation was supposed to be the next big thing in MMORPGs. So what went wrong?
A Rocky Launch Despite Strong Player Interest
When Ashes of Creation’s early access went live on December 11, the initial numbers looked promising. The $50 game quickly drew 30,000 concurrent players on Steam—a solid launch for any MMORPG in today’s crowded market.
But the honeymoon period didn’t last long. Within hours, negative reviews started flooding in, dragging the game to a “Mixed” rating with more than half of early access reviewers expressing disappointment.
The Main Problems Plaguing Ashes of Creation
Players have identified several critical issues that are souring the early access experience:
Technical Nightmares
- Server overload: Intrepid Studios’ servers couldn’t handle the launch day traffic
- Login problems: Players struggled to create or link their Intrepid accounts to Steam
- Frequent crashes: Many users reported being kicked out repeatedly
- Connection errors: Server instability made the game nearly unplayable for some
Content Concerns
Beyond technical issues, fans are questioning whether there’s enough substance to justify the price tag and development time. One frustrated original Kickstarter backer from 2017 wrote: “Now, almost nine years later, this game is 20% ready?”
Missing Rewards
Adding insult to injury, players who purchased cosmetic items and mounts during earlier development phases report that these items haven’t been delivered. When you’ve been supporting a game for years, not receiving what you paid for stings even more.
A Decade-Long Journey to… This?
Let’s put this in perspective. Ashes of Creation has an interesting—and lengthy—development history:
The timeline:
- 2015: Development reportedly begins
- 2016: Official announcement
- Kickstarter campaign: Raised millions from thousands of eager fans
- Major publisher deal: Signed, then abandoned years later
- Independent development: Intrepid Studios goes it alone
- 2024: Early access finally launches after nearly 10 years
For a game that’s been in development for almost a decade, many players expected something more polished. The fact that it’s still labeled “early access” (technically the second phase of alpha testing) hasn’t softened the criticism much.
Intrepid Studios Promises Fixes
To their credit, the developers aren’t ignoring the backlash. Intrepid Studios has acknowledged the negative reviews and issued reassurances on Twitter, thanking players for their purchases and emphasizing that the team is “working hard to create the best possible game.”
But promises only go so far when players can’t even log in reliably or access content they’ve already paid for.
Can Ashes of Creation Recover?
Here’s the thing: a rough early access launch doesn’t have to be a death sentence. Gaming history is full of comeback stories.
There’s Precedent for Recovery
Take Path of Exile 2 as an example. The game dropped to “Mostly Negative” reviews back in April 2025, but through consistent updates and addressing player concerns, it climbed back to “Very Positive” in recent reviews.
Why Ashes of Creation could turn it around:
- It’s still in early access with room for improvement
- The developer appears committed to ongoing development
- The core concept still has appeal—there’s a reason 30,000 players showed up
- Technical issues are fixable with time and resources
Why recovery might be difficult:
- Ten years of development has raised expectations sky-high
- Trust has been eroded by missing rewards and content concerns
- The MMORPG graveyard is littered with promising titles that couldn’t course-correct
- Players have limited patience for incomplete experiences, even in early access
The MMORPG Graveyard Warning
The harsh reality is that many MMORPGs don’t survive rocky launches. The genre is unforgiving—players need to feel their time investment is worthwhile, and negative word-of-mouth spreads fast.
Fans are already warning that Ashes of Creation could join the growing list of failed MMORPGs if Intrepid Studios doesn’t act quickly and decisively.
What Needs to Happen Next
For Ashes of Creation to salvage its reputation and build a sustainable player base, Intrepid Studios needs to:
Immediate priorities:
- Stabilize servers and fix login issues (table stakes)
- Deliver promised rewards to restore trust with longtime supporters
- Add meaningful content to justify the $50 price tag and decade of development
- Communicate transparently about the roadmap and realistic timelines
- Listen to feedback and implement changes that address core concerns
The next few months will be critical. Either Intrepid Studios demonstrates they can respond to criticism and improve the game, or Ashes of Creation becomes another cautionary tale in MMORPG development.
Should You Buy Ashes of Creation Right Now?
If you’re considering jumping into Ashes of Creation’s early access, here’s the honest assessment:
Wait if:
- You expect a polished, content-rich experience
- You have low tolerance for technical issues
- You want your $50 to go toward a proven product
Consider it if:
- You enjoy being part of early development and providing feedback
- You’re patient with bugs and limited content
- You believe in the game’s long-term vision and want to support it
Remember, this is genuinely early access—not a soft launch disguised as one.
Related Gaming News
Stay updated on the latest in gaming:
- Xbox Developer Direct 2026 January Showcase Announcement
- Rockstar GTA 6 Developer Firings UK Government Response
- New Alien Survival Horror Game Leak 2028 Eidos Montreal
The Bottom Line
Ashes of Creation’s early access launch is a classic case of high expectations meeting harsh reality. After a decade of development and millions in crowdfunding, fans expected more than server issues, missing content, and unrealized promises.
That said, the game isn’t dead yet. With 30,000 players showing up on day one, there’s clearly interest in what Ashes of Creation could become. The question is whether Intrepid Studios can execute on their vision before that interest evaporates.
The coming months will reveal whether this MMORPG can rise from the ashes—or becomes another cautionary tale about overpromising and underdelivering.