Wondering if you should meet Isabella in the garden in Chapter 3 of Mafia: The Old Country? Learn what happens, if it impacts the story, and what you gain from this choice.
Should You Meet Isabella in the Garden in Mafia: The Old Country?
At the start of Chapter 3, Pizzu, you receive a letter from Isabella asking Enzo to meet her in the garden if he wants to talk again.
After Luca’s warning in the previous chapter, players might hesitate—but the choice is straightforward:
Yes, you should meet Isabella in the garden.
While this choice doesn’t affect the overall story, it triggers a unique interaction and unlocks the Garden Rendezvous Trophy/Achievement.
Plus, by going to the garden, players can pick up the Astuzia charm, which increases the area of effect for all thrown items—a handy bonus for combat.
What Happens When You Meet Isabella? (Mild Spoilers)
Meeting Isabella leads to a brief, atmospheric conversation where Enzo and Isabella reflect on recent events in Collezolfo.
There’s some gentle flirting, but the moment is cut short when Tino arrives, warning Enzo about getting too close to the Don’s daughter.
Tino also comments oddly on Isabella not wearing the shoes.
Despite the tension, this scene has no lasting impact on your relationships or the story. So Tino remains cold toward Enzo regardless of your actions during this encounter.
Are There Meaningful Choices in Mafia: The Old Country?
In short, Mafia: The Old Country doesn’t offer choices that change its story. The only major decisions are around whether to kill certain characters when given the option.
Even if you choose not to take action, someone else will do it. For example, sparing a character in Chapter 13 unlocks the Man of Honor Trophy/Achievement.
So, meeting Isabella is entirely optional but rewarding for players interested in exploring the game world and earning achievements without any narrative consequence.
If I Explain it in Short
- Meeting Isabella unlocks a special achievement and unique dialogue.
- You receive the Astuzia charm at the garden, boosting thrown weapon effectiveness.
- The choice does not affect the story or character relationships.
- Mafia: The Old Country generally offers very limited narrative branching.
- Optional decisions mostly reward achievements rather than impact plot.
FAQs
No, it’s an optional scene with no major story consequences, so no Isabella will not affect the main story..
You unlock the Garden Rendezvous achievement and you will get the Astuzia charm.
Yes, but you can replay Chapter 3 anytime you want to meet her and unlock the achievement.
Choices do exist, but they rarely impact the main story and mostly unlock achievements like Man of Honor.
In Chapter 3, that little garden chat with Isabella is a nice detour for atmosphere, a little character insight, and also a useful reward. It’s definitely worth the visit if you want the damn full Mafia: The Old Country experience.
