TL;DR
- Yes, you can replay missions — but only after unlocking the Batcave in Chapter 2.
- Go to the Batcave and interact with the Batcomputer to open the Case Log.
- Pick any completed mission and choose Story Mode or Free Play.
- Free Play lets you use any unlocked character to reach hidden collectibles.
- Each mission shows a completion percentage so you know exactly what you missed.
Missed a WayneTech Cache? Skipped a Red Brick? Don’t worry. LEGO Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight lets you replay any completed mission. You just need to know where to look — and it is not the pause menu.
This guide walks you through every step. It also explains the difference between Story Mode and Free Play, and gives you tips to make your replay runs worth it.
Can You Replay Missions in LEGO Batman Legacy of the Dark Knight?
Yes, you absolutely can. Mission replay is built into the game through the Batcomputer inside the Batcave. Once you unlock it, you can go back to any mission you have already completed.
A lot of players miss this feature early on because it is not explained clearly. You will not find a level select on the pause screen or the main menu. The Batcomputer is the only way in.
This matters a lot if you are going for 100% completion. Many collectibles — like Batcave Trophies, WayneTech Caches, and Red Bricks — are easy to miss on your first run. Replaying lets you clean them up later.
When Does Mission Replay Unlock?
Mission replay is not available from the start of the game. The feature is tied to story progress.
You get access to the Batcave at the beginning of Chapter 2. Once you are inside the Batcave, the Batcomputer becomes available and the Case Log menu opens up. From that point on, you can replay any mission you have finished.
So if you are still in Chapter 1 and wondering why you cannot replay anything, just keep going. The Batcave unlock happens early in the next chapter and it does not take long to reach.
How to Replay Missions Using the Batcomputer
Here is the full step-by-step process to replay a mission:
Step 1: Fast Travel to the Batcave
Open your map in Gotham City and fast travel back to the Batcave hub. You cannot fast travel directly to the Batcomputer, but you can get close. Once you land in the Batcave, grapple or walk over to the central operations area where the Batcomputer sits.
Step 2: Interact with the Batcomputer Chair
Walk up to the Batcomputer terminal and press the interact button. Batman will sit down at the chair and the Case Log will appear on screen. This is the mission replay menu.
Step 3: Open the Case Log
The Case Log lists every story mission and chapter you have completed so far. Each entry shows a completion percentage so you can instantly see which missions still have collectibles left. If a mission has a yellow checkmark icon, it means you already hit 100% on that one.
Step 4: Choose a Mission to Replay
Select the mission you want to revisit. The game breaks each chapter down into smaller mission segments, not just full chapters. This is a big help. You do not have to replay an entire multi-part chapter — you can jump straight into the specific section where you missed something.
Step 5: Pick Story Mode or Free Play
Before loading, the game asks you to choose a mode:
- Story Mode — You play as the original characters for that mission. Your options are limited but it works fine for straightforward replays.
- Free Play — You can swap between any character you have unlocked. This is the mode you want for collecting missed items, since different characters have different gadgets and abilities needed to reach hidden spots.
Most of the time, Free Play is the better choice when you are going back for collectibles.
Story Mode vs Free Play: Which One Should You Use?
This is one of the most important decisions when replaying missions. Here is a simple breakdown:
- Story Mode is good if you just want to experience the mission again or test something specific with the original character loadout.
- Free Play is better for 100% runs. It lets you bring in characters with abilities that were not available during your first playthrough. Some secrets are locked behind gadgets or suit abilities that only certain characters have.
Many WayneTech Caches and hidden areas require specific abilities to unlock. Check out all the suits in LEGO Batman Legacy of the Dark Knight to see which characters can access which areas during Free Play.
What Can You Collect by Replaying Missions?
Replaying missions is mainly about picking up what you missed. Here is what you are looking for:
- WayneTech Caches — These are the main in-mission collectibles. Each mission has five of them. Collecting them gives you WayneTech currency to spend on upgrades.
- Red Bricks — Each mission has one Red Brick. These unlock modifiers and cosmetic options for your playstyle.
- Batcave Trophies — These come from destroying specific sets of themed objects inside missions. For example, breaking all five Surfboards in a level earns you a Surfboard trophy for your Batcave. You can see more on Surfboard locations in New Beginnings and Bonsai Tree locations in Infiltration.
- Challenge objectives — Some missions have optional challenge tasks tied to rewards. Replays give you another shot at those.
Replaying missions does not affect your main story progress. You are only improving your collectible completion percentage for that specific mission.
Pro Tips for Replaying Missions
Unlock the Collectible Detective Skill First
Before you start replaying missions, it is worth unlocking the Collectible Detective skill from the Exploration skill tree. This adds a proximity indicator near your Focus bar that alerts you when a collectible is close by. It makes hunting in replays much easier and saves time.
The skill tree opens up more as you progress through the campaign, so it is usually better to push through the story first and then come back for cleanup.
Use the Completion Percentage as Your Guide
The Case Log shows each mission’s completion percentage right on the screen. Start with the missions that are farthest from 100%. Missions showing something like 60% or 70% likely have multiple collectibles still missing, so those are worth hitting first.
Play Free Play for All Collectible Runs
Almost every time you go back for collectibles, use Free Play. Some items are hidden behind puzzles that require specific abilities. If you played as Batman in Story Mode and could not reach a certain cache, the right character in Free Play will open it up immediately.
Plan Around Co-Op If You Play with a Friend
If you play with someone else, replaying missions together in co-op is a great way to split up the collectible search. Here is how to play co-op in LEGO Batman Legacy of the Dark Knight if you need to set that up first.
What If the Replay Option Is Missing?
If you go to the Batcomputer and cannot see the Case Log or the replay option, there are two likely reasons:
- You have not reached Chapter 2 yet and the Batcave has not unlocked.
- You are still in the early part of Chapter 2 and the Batcomputer feature has not been formally introduced by the story yet.
In both cases, just continue the main story a little further. The Case Log unlocks naturally without any extra steps needed.
Is This the Same as Level Select?
Effectively, yes. The Batcomputer’s Case Log works like a traditional level select system. The difference is that it is tied to the Batcave hub world rather than a menu on the title screen. Once you are familiar with fast travelling to the Batcave, accessing it becomes second nature.
The system is actually more useful than a standard level select because it shows your completion data right in the menu. You always know which missions need attention.
LEGO Batman Legacy of the Dark Knight: More Guides
If you are working toward 100% completion, here are a few more things to look into:
- LEGO Batman Legacy of the Dark Knight PC requirements — check this before buying on PC.
- LEGO Batman Legacy of the Dark Knight redeem codes — free suits and extras you do not want to miss.
The game is available on multiple platforms. You can grab it on Steam, Epic Games Store, and PlayStation Store.
Wrapping Up with the Note
Replaying missions in LEGO Batman Legacy of the Dark Knight is straightforward once you know where to go. The Batcomputer in the Batcave is your hub for everything mission-related. The Case Log shows you exactly what you missed, and Free Play gives you the tools to fix it.
The best approach is to play through the story first, unlock the Collectible Detective skill, and then come back to clean up missions with the full character roster available. That way, you are not replaying blindly — you have every ability you need to reach every hidden spot.
